In 2025, TMC and Mamata Banerjee oppose West Bengal’s voter list update (SIR), citing democracy concerns, but several myths are fueling their resistance.
Myth 1: SIR Is Just “Votebandi” / Targeted Suppression
TMC alleges that SIR is being rushed to disenfranchise voters ahead of elections. However, SIR is a legally mandated exercise under the Representation of the People Act to update and clean voter rolls, a standard democratic process.
Myth 2: It’s a Plot to Exclude Minority or Bengali‑Speaking Voters
TMC claims SIR is motivated by a political agenda to target specific groups. While political fears are real, critics argue that TMC’s resistance partly stems from the risk of losing names that may have helped its vote bank.
Myth 3: The Use of 2002 Data Is Unfair/Outdated
TMC has questioned the use of the 2002 SIR data despite delimitation changes. They argue this could wrongly disqualify legitimate voters, raising a serious procedural concern.
Myth 4: SIR Puts Vulnerable People Under Fear / Deletes Genuine Voters
TMC alleges that door-to-door verification under SIR is creating an environment of fear, potentially leading to wrongful deletions. They warn of protests and legal action if people’s names are removed unjustly.
Myth 5: Mamata Banerjee Herself Is Avoiding the Process / Being Hypocritical
There were reports that Mamata had filled her own SIR form, which she later denied. She clarified she had not submitted anything until everyone else had, countering claims that she’s simply playing political games.
